Who is to blame for the Golden Cage Sherlock Holmes Chapter One quest

One of the most interesting plot investigations, during which you are offered several options at once. There are 6 endings in total, and they are different in content, although three of them are similar in the final cut-scene. Spoilers will follow!

So the elephant trampled his master Theodore Gilden. You found a dart in his paw. Both Paul and Arthur Swift have such darts. So who had more reasons? Ultimately, you can:

• Blame and execute the elephant.
• Blame the elephant, but ask Imogen to save him. The girl will sell the elephant to a stranger.
• Blame Paul and arrest him.
• Blame Paul, let him go and let Goliath be executed.
• Blame Arthur and arrest him.
• Blame Arthur, let him go and let Goliath be executed.

It’s hard to understand, but it was Arthur Swift who had more desire. In this game, if you solve the case correctly, you earn 80 coins. So, only if Arthur is accused will you earn 80 coins. And it doesn't matter if you execute him, you arrest him or release him by executing the elephant.

The only point is when you accuse Paul and then let him go, he says that you first hang up a fake case, and then try to go back on your head. But if you accuse Arthur, and then decide to let him go, will he begin to thank you for the good??mind. The words of a true killer.

Thus, if you want to close the case correctly, blame Arthur, and then act according to your conscience - let him go and execute the elephant or arrest Arthur. In both cases, Imogen will be grateful to you. As in the rest of the cases, if you execute an elephant.

She will be ungrateful and nervous if you ask to save the elephant, blaming him, or arrest Paul, who is her only protector. But in any case, these four endings will bring you only 30 coins.